Social protection is often framed as a cost to the state, with critics arguing that expanding social grants is fiscally unsustainable and diverts resources from economic growth. However, new research by the Institute for Economic Justice (IEJ) challenges this assumption, finding that social protection spending can generate substantial economic activity and increase tax revenue in South Africa.
In The multiplier effect of social protection in South Africa, Siyanda Baduza, Kelle Howson and Hamadziripi Tamukamoyo examine the macroeconomic effects of social protection spending over the past two decades. Using structural vector autoregression (SVAR) modelling and public economic and budget data, the study finds that:
- Social protection generates a cumulative economic multiplier of 4.25. An unexpected R1 increase in social protection spending is associated with an additional R4.25 in real GDP over 10 quarters.
- Social grants have an even greater multiplier effect. An unexpected R1 increase in social grant expenditure generates R5.53 in real GDP over the same period.
- Social protection spending increases tax revenue. The cumulative tax revenue multiplier for overall social protection is 2.56, while the multiplier for direct social assistance is 2.99. This indicates that increased economic activity associated with social spending can generate additional revenue for the fiscus.
- Household consumption drives the economic impact. The findings show that social protection stimulates economic activity primarily by increasing household consumption, with no statistically significant evidence that broader social protection spending crowds out private investment.
The study also compares these findings with the multiplier effect of overall government expenditure, which it estimates at just 0.18. This highlights the importance of looking beyond aggregate government spending to understand how different forms of public expenditure affect economic growth.
These findings have important implications for South Africa’s fiscal and social policy debates. At a time when the affordability of social grants, particularly the Social Relief of Distress (SRD) grant, remains contested, the research challenges the assumption that expanding social protection necessarily undermines fiscal sustainability. Instead, it demonstrates how cash transfers can support household livelihoods, stimulate demand and strengthen the tax base.
The findings reinforce the case for treating social protection as an investment in economic activity and poverty reduction, rather than simply a cost to the public purse. While the precise effects of future expansions may vary depending on how they are funded and implemented, the evidence suggests that poverty reduction and fiscal sustainability need not be competing objectives.
Social protection is both a social imperative and a potential driver of inclusive economic growth. Recognising its multiplier effects is essential to developing fiscal policies that respond to poverty and inequality while supporting a more resilient economy.
