Skip to content
Presentation | Debates on SA wealth taxation

Author: Liso Mdutyana

Liso Mdutyana presented Debates on SA wealth taxation at a post-MTBPS discussion hosted by the Alternative Information and Development Centre (AIDC) and Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung (FES), as part of the Tax Justice Network. The presentation examined advocacy for wealth taxation and assessed arguments raised by National Treasury and civil society organisations.

The case for wealth taxation

Proponents argue that a net wealth tax could generate sustainable revenue by targeting the substantial wealth held by ultra-high-net-worth individuals. The additional revenue could support public investment in infrastructure, human capital and social protection, contributing to economic growth and addressing historical inequalities linked to colonialism and apartheid.

The presentation also considers wealth taxation as a solidarity measure while highlighting concerns about capital flight, tax evasion and the importance of directing revenue towards productive, high-impact public investment.

Arguments against wealth taxation

Counterarguments include concerns that South Africa already taxes wealth through instruments such as estate duty, donation tax, capital gains tax, property taxes and securities transfer tax. Critics warn that introducing another tax could encourage wealthy individuals to move capital or assets elsewhere, potentially weakening the broader tax base.

International experiences also raise questions about administrative complexity, collection costs and the revenue lost through behavioural responses.

Design and implementation challenges

The potential impact of a wealth tax depends on its rate, scope, administration and use of revenue. Effective implementation would require measures to address evasion, strengthen enforcement and ensure that revenue supports clearly defined public priorities.

Conclusion

The presentation identifies important questions for further research and advocacy, including how to address capital flight, which groups and stakeholders should be engaged, and what strategies civil society can use to advance wealth taxation. It also raises a broader question about whether policy should focus on taxing accumulated wealth or encouraging its productive use to support economic development and redistribution.

DOWNLOAD PRESENTATION (PDF)

Related

Explore more of our work connected to this topic.

Back To Top